Surveillance
cameras spark four public meetings
Wednesday, May 26, 2004 - John Driscoll
A heated debate is expected tonight at the first of four public forums on
a proposal for surveillance cameras in downtown Peterborough.
The proposal from the Downtown Business Improvement
Area (DBIA) is scheduled from 7 to 9 p.m. at Princess Gardens, 100 Charlotte
Street.
Tonight’s town hall meeting is being hosted by
the city as part of the guidelines from the Privacy Commissioner on proposals
for use of surveillance cameras, says Walter Johnstone, DBIA executive
director.
“I expect we will get some very polarized viewpoints
at this first meeting,” Walter says. “With four meetings,
we should get a continuum of opinions.”
The DBIA has asked city council to approve the installation
of five surveillance cameras in the downtown core, igniting a backlash
in the form of the Stop the Cameras Coalition.
The DBIA would pay the installation costs, estimated
at about $60,000, with the city picking up the operating tab for monitoring
the system, according to the DBIA proposal.
Surveillance cameras have been shown to be effective
in deterring crime in other centres, Johnstone says. There have been some
serious crimes downtown such as assaults, a bank robbery and a swarming
as well as about $50,000 worth of windows broken annually, he points out.
“We surveyed our membership and 83 per cent of
those who responded are in favour of installing the cameras,” he
says. “We didn’t get one property owner who was opposed to
the idea.”
The DBIA has more than 560 members and 20 per cent (about
112) responded to the survey, Johnstone said. “For our members,
that is an exceptional response to a survey,” he says.
The coalition has been circulating a petition opposed
to the surveillance cameras and established a website where arguments
against the installation of the cameras are listed.
The coalition argues that the cameras will not deter crime but rather
displace it and quotes statistics from other jurisdictions to back up
that argument.
“The cameras are an infringement on our basic
civil liberties and fundamental rights as Canadians,” the Coalition
states.
The Coalition claims there is no mechanism for public
scrutiny to ensure the cameras and videos will not be used for the wrong
purposes. Johnstone says there are rigorous standards that have to be
met regarding the use and monitoring of the cameras.
One of the privacy commissioner’s guidelines is
to have community consultation and city hall decided to hold four meetings
for public input. Additional meetings will be held June 3 at Market Hall
on George Street, June 9 at St. George’s Anglican Church on Braidwood
Avenue and June 16 at the Chamber of Commerce board room with all meetings
scheduled from 7 to 9 p.m.
After the last meeting city staff will present a recommendation
to city council for a decision. If approved, the cameras could be in operation
by the fall, Johnstone says.
|